Download the pilgrim template, print, and cut out the pieces you need.

Paint a paper plate in 1-2 thin coats of skin-colored paint. Let dry completely before moving on.

Begin to create the hat by gluing the hat band to the base of the hat. Trim off any paper that hangs off the sides.

Place the outer buckle in the middle of the hat band, then glue the inner buckle to the middle of the outer buckle.

Next, glue the hat to the top of the hair.

Position the eyes near the middle of the paper plate and glue one on each side.

Glue the mouth in the middle of the plate, just below the eyes.

Take the tongue and glue it to the bottom of the mouth.

Next, glue the cheeks on both sides of the mouth.

Use a black marker to draw on the pilgrim's nose, just below the eyes.

Finish up by gluing the hair and hat piece to the top of the paper plate, so the hair hangs on top of the eyes.